Head-to-head · Roadside Emergency Kits & Warning Lights
CARTMAN DOT Warning Triangles (3-Pack) vs MARCALA LED Road Flares (3-Pack)
Both products side by side: five criteria scores, manufacturer list price and published specs. The conclusion below is generated from the scores — no opinions added.
What the scores say
On overall score, MARCALA LED Road Flares (3-Pack) ranks higher: 4.1 vs 3.5.
- CARTMAN DOT Warning Triangles (3-Pack) leads on value (4.0 vs 3.5).
- MARCALA LED Road Flares (3-Pack) leads on fit & compatibility (4.5 vs 3.5), warranty & support (4.5 vs 2.0).
- Tied on spec strength, build quality.
- List price is not published for at least one of the two, so price is not compared.
| Criterion | CARTMAN DOT Warning Triangles (3-Pack) | MARCALA LED Road Flares (3-Pack) |
|---|---|---|
| Scores | ||
| Overall | 3.5/5 | 4.1/5 |
| Spec strength | 4.0 Only device in this group that cites the actual federal standard (FMVSS 125) and ships three units for proper spacing; it has no light source, so it depends on headlights to reflect. | 4.0 15 LEDs, 9 modes, IP67 and a stated visibility distance are more published numbers than the Ecoangel offers; it gives up the Ecoangel's rechargeable cell and magnet. |
| Build quality | 4.0 Sand-filled 2.98 lb bases to resist truck wash; some listing feedback mentions the carrying case cracking, which the spec sheet doesn't address. | 4.0 IP67 ABS body that floats and the maker calls crush-proof; the only flare here with a water rating. |
| Fit & compatibility | 3.5 At 9.2 lb per set it is the heaviest item in this group and takes real trunk space, versus 1 lb for three Ecoangel discs. | 4.5 Works on any vehicle with no charging; replaceable batteries mean a disc that sat for two years still lights up with fresh cells. |
| Warranty & support | 2.0 No warranty term and no brand website; MARCALA states lifetime, Everlit 1 year. | 4.5 Lifetime warranty stated by a US-based seller — the strongest coverage in the category, though there is no brand website to read the terms. |
| Value | 4.0 No list price to score; three standards-cited triangles with no batteries to replace is the cheapest ownership in this group. | 3.5 No list price to score; the kit adds a whistle, cutter and spare batteries, but you will keep buying batteries where the Ecoangel recharges. |
| Manufacturer list price | ||
| MSRP | Not published as of — | Not published as of — |
| Published specs | ||
| Piece count | 3 folding triangles | 3 LED flares (batteries installed), bonus batteries, carry bag, multi-tool with seatbelt cutter, whistle, gift box |
| Battery | None | Disposable; 9 batteries installed (3 per flare) plus spares; type not stated by the manufacturer |
| Model | FBA_WT121106B | LEDPRNT |
| Warranty | Not published | Lifetime, per the manufacturer listing |
| Size | 17 x 17 in reflective panel with fluorescent plate | Not published |
| Weight | 2.98 lb per triangle; 9.2 lb per set | Not published |
| Base | Rotatable, sand-filled weighted base | Not published |
| Setup | Tool-free fold-out with snap-fit | Not published |
| Compliance | Manufacturer states DOT approved and compliant with FMVSS 571.125 (warning devices for stopped vehicles) | Not published |
| Light | None (passive reflective; no battery) | Not published |
| Light modes | Not published | 9 flashing modes; 3 white LEDs double as a work light |
| LED count | Not published | 15 LEDs per flare |
| Visibility | Not published | Manufacturer claims visible from over 5,200 ft at night |
| Water rating | Not published | IP67; floats |
| Body | Not published | ABS, crush-proof, scratch-free base |
| Mounting | Not published | Flat disc (no magnet listed) |
| DOT claim | Not published | Manufacturer states "DOT compliant"; no standard or test report cited |
| Best for | ||
| Best for | Owner-operators and fleet drivers; RV and trailer towing; Anyone who wants a federal standard behind the device | Drivers who want a set-and-forget trunk flare; New-driver gift kits; Boaters who need a floating signal light |
Scores are calculated from the manufacturers' published specifications. BaniCar has not handled either unit. Specs and availability change — verify on the listing.
CARTMAN DOT Warning Triangles (3-Pack) on Amazon MARCALA LED Road Flares (3-Pack) on Amazon
Full reviews: CARTMAN DOT Warning Triangles (3-Pack) · MARCALA LED Road Flares (3-Pack). Updated Oct 16, 2026.